Phil Gingrey: Akin 'partly right' on rape comment
by DONNA CASSATA, Associated Press
Jan 11, 2013 | 4709 views | 10 10 comments | 6 6 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Phil Gingrey
Phil Gingrey
slideshow
WASHINGTON (AP) — Republican Rep. Phil Gingrey, an OB-GYN since 1975, said former Rep. Todd Akin was "partly right" when he said women's bodies can avoid pregnancy in cases of "legitimate rape."

However, the six-term Georgia lawmaker issued a statement Friday, the day after his comments, saying his position was misconstrued and that he neither defends nor stands by Akin's remark.

Gingrey spoke to constituents at a Thursday breakfast meeting and commented on both Akin and Richard Mourdock, two Republican Senate candidates tripped up by their clumsy comments last year about rape and abortion, according to the Marietta Daily Journal in Georgia. Republicans disavowed Akin after his statement, and Mourdock was widely criticized when he said pregnancy resulting from rape is "something God intended."

"Part of the reason the Dems still control the Senate is because of comments made in Missouri by Todd Akin and Indiana by Mourdock were considered a little bit over the top," Gingrey said, according to the newspaper. "Mourdock basically said 'Look, if there is conception in the aftermath of a rape, that's still a child, and it's a child of God, essentially.' Now, in Indiana, that cost him the election.

"And in Missouri, Todd Akin . was asked by a local news source about rape and he said, 'Look, in a legitimate rape situation' — and what he meant by legitimate rape was just, look, someone can say I was raped: a scared-to-death 15-year-old that becomes impregnated by her boyfriend and then has to tell her parents — that's pretty tough — and might on some occasion say, 'Hey, I was raped.' That's what he meant when he said legitimate rape versus non-legitimate rape.

"I don't find anything so horrible about that," Gingrey said. "But then he went on and said that in a situation of rape, of a legitimate rape, a woman's body has a way of shutting down so the pregnancy would not occur. He's partly right on that."

He made the comments to the Smyrna Area Council of the Cobb Chamber of Commerce, according to the newspaper.

Gingrey added that he has been an OB-GYN since 1975 and understands pregnancies.

"And I've delivered lots of babies, and I know about these things. It is true. We tell infertile couples all the time that are having trouble conceiving because of the woman not ovulating, 'Just relax. Drink a glass of wine. And don't be so tense and uptight, because all that adrenaline can cause you not to ovulate.' So he was partially right, wasn't he?" Gingrey said. "But the fact that a woman may have already ovulated 12 hours before she is raped, you're not going to prevent a pregnancy there by a woman's body shutting anything down, because the horse has already left the barn, so to speak. And yet the media took that and tore it apart," the congressman said.

Gingrey is co-chairman of the GOP Doctors Caucus, which was formed in March 2009 to challenge President Barack Obama's health care overhaul. He also is a member of the Health subcommittee of the Energy and Commerce panel.

He sought to explain his comments, saying in a statement issued by his office Friday, "At a breakfast yesterday morning, I was asked why Democrats made abortion a central theme of the presidential campaign. I do not defend, nor do I stand by, the remarks made by Rep. Akin and Mr. Mourdock. In my attempt to provide context as to what I presumed they meant, my position was misconstrued."

Gingrey's initial comments drew widespread criticism.

"Just when I think Republicans can't possibly be any more wrong when it comes to women, they find a new low. In one fell swoop, Republican Congressman Phil Gingrey said women regularly lie about being raped, that they're able to prevent a pregnancy simply by 'being tense and uptight,' and that Todd Akin had a point," said Stephanie Schriock, President of EMILY's List.

Jesse Ferguson of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee said it was "alarming and telling" that the head of the GOP Doctors Caucus shared Akin's views.
Comments
(10)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
WWrome
|
January 14, 2013
But much more importantly, Phil, I am fairly certain it wasn't God's will for your hair to be that color. So please just lay off the "Just for Men".
mindtrain
|
January 13, 2013
This is just another reason women don't report rape. We have idiots who make comments like this. I would think that as a former OBGYN, Mr. Gingrey would understand that there are no magic buttons for woman to push during rape. Unfortunately she cannot just shut down her ovulation during a rape to prevent getting pregnant. I am sure if this was their wife or daughter that had experience such a horrific act, that they would not being made these rude comments.
Trelicious
|
January 11, 2013
These are the days when it's okay to have any Democratic opinion, but your career and life is ruined if you have any conservative opinion. It's only the beginning. A media that turns a blind eye to every Democratic misdeed and takes every Democrat at their word is not a good thing for America, but it's too late to fix now.
wheninrome
|
January 15, 2013
How long did it take you to formulate (unsuccessfully, I might add) a pro-Republican/anti-Democrat response to such a ridiculous line of thinking? A few simple questions: do you believe that there exists a brand of "legitimate rape?" Do you believe that woman's body has the ability to shut-down in the case of a rape? If said raped woman's body does not shut down, do you believe that it is God's plan to force this woman to give birth?

My God, who can bring logic back into the discussion? I'm nauseous.
Trelicious
|
January 16, 2013
I was referring to the treatment of Democrats by the media, not what Phil said. Legitimate rape is a termed used by law enforcement to denote those rapes that actually occur and not the false rape claims that investigators are overwhelmed with. However, it's much easier to be nauseous because your tummy can't handle reality than it is to talk about a difficult subject.

Phil says something stupid, it's national, front page news for a week. A democrat allows his sex offender, illegal alien staff member to avoid arrest by ICE until after the election is over, gets one day on Page 12.

Did I convince the unconvincable? :D
LadyK88
|
January 11, 2013
This is what is wrong with America. Everybody is so worried about what everyone else does with their lives. All the political push and pull over things like abortion is irritating. Why are these two men so concerned about babies that aren't theirs, and women who may or may not have been raped but want abortions. That isn't going to get our country out of it's tremendous debt.

I bet they both also hate women who have more babies than income and need food stamps to feed the kids they chose not to abort. I bet they both also walk around their house drinking expensive bourbon while figuring out what lie to tell their wife so they can get out to see their mistress.

I don't honestly care what they do. Saints or sinners? No business of mine. I just wish politicians and party representatives would stay out of things like this and focus on things like digging this country out of it's hole. That's one thing most everyone wants.

I won't even fault them if their ideas are bad. As long as they are working on something constructive besides how else to take away some more of our rights in this "free country" they speak of then I'm all for it.
KingPellinore
|
January 11, 2013
Way to put party rhetoric over medical science, Phil.
FormerRomanJr.
|
January 11, 2013
King, You smarter than an OBGYN?..

I had you pegged as a liberal arts kind of guy?
KingPellinore
|
January 16, 2013
"Recent remarks by a member of the US House of Representatives suggesting that “women who are victims of ‘legitimate rape’ rarely get pregnant” are medically inaccurate, offensive, and dangerous.

Each year in the US, 10,000–15,000 abortions occur among women whose pregnancies are a result of reported rape or incest. An unknown number of pregnancies resulting from rape are carried to term. There is absolutely no veracity to the claim that “If it’s a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to shut that whole thing down.” A woman who is raped has no control over ovulation, fertilization, or implantation of a fertilized egg (ie, pregnancy). To suggest otherwise contradicts basic biological truths.

Any person forced to submit to sexual intercourse against his or her will is the victim of rape, a heinous crime. There are no varying degrees of rape. To suggest otherwise is inaccurate and insulting and minimizes the serious physical and psychological repercussions for all victims of rape."

-The American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
Postings are not edited and are the responsibility of the author. You agree not to post comments that are abusive, threatening or obscene. Postings may be removed at our discretion.